What if Luke is actually Snoke? Bear with me here. I think that a careful examination of footage from Episode IV will show that this guy has been with the Dark Side of the Force since we first saw him. Don’t believe me? Ask any bartender.
I got this theory from an excerpt from the Steele Wars podcast with guest Mr. Sunday Movies (embedded at the bottom of this post.) And while I rip off their idea, I’m going to expand on it, upgrading Luke from maker of the dick move to obvious Sith mastermind.
Exhibit A: Luke Simply Enters the Bar
Luke is how old? 16? 17, maybe? I’m pretty sure that he is under age. A seventeen year-old who walks into your average dive bar here on Earth puts the whole operation in jeopardy from the Bureau of Liquor Control. The Cantina is in The Empire. This is how Stormtroopers handle a simple case of suspected receipt of stolen goods.
Can you imagine how they’d handle someone they want to make an example of?
Exhibit B: Luke Tries Bringing Undesirables Into the Bar
Really Luke? Droids? In a bar? Have you no social graces?
Exhibit C: Luke Tells His Friends to Piss Off So He Can Get In
The bar straight out discriminates against Threepio and R2. And Luke, who is focused on sneaking in while underage, just outright shoves them back out into the street!
Your hallmark, it is not!
A true Sith can be evil on both sides of an issue!
Exhibit D: Darth Maul Wouldn’t Be This Big of a Jerk When Ordering
Bartenders will take this piece of evidence by itself and scream, “Guilty!” Luke walks up to the bartender, who has his back turned, is clearly in the weeds, and has a room full of patrons who will clearly not take well having their drinks delayed, and grabs his sleeve.
This is not cool, folks. And not only was it a Dark Side move a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away, Luke probably also knew he was setting a bad example for young movie viewers a long time later, in a galaxy far, far away form Tatooine. Don’t tell me a Sith isn’t capable of projecting his evil beyond the confines of a story he’s a fictional character in. They have some serious power, those guys. If you don’t think Luke’s “dick move” rises to the level of true evil, look at the hapless bartender’s reaction.
That is the face of a man who wants to eighty-six punks like Luke three times an hour, but he works in a “hive of scum and villany”, so if he did, his tips would suffer or he’d get shot. Instead, Luke has this guy so terrified that the drink he hands over doesn’t even kill Luke. This bar serves fifty alien species, at least one thing on offer there would kill this kid. If he wasn’t a Sith, of course.
Luke, Sith or not, you tug on a bartender’s sleeve to order on earth, and your cocktail will at the very least contain 3/4 oz. of saliva.
Exhibit E: Luke Gets Some Dude’s Hand Cut Off
Why does the fight start? The (admittedly rough and tumble) patrons to Luke’s left quite politely make room for him when he first approaches the bar. So when does the apparent hostility arise? Why, after Luke is such a dick to the bartender!Luke has to know his behavior is unacceptable to them, but he callously shrugs off their concerns. This quite foreseeably enrages them, but Luke knows he can duck (or be thrown) out of the way and there standing behind him is a galacticly famous wizard with a magic sword. The results for the concerned patrons are predictable…
…especially in stories in the Star Wars universe.
See? Case closed: Luke is clearly a Sith from moment one. If that is the case, then how do you explain the events of Episodes IV, V, and VI? Clearly, this is Luke getting rid of the Emperor and his own father to clear the way for himself. He then waits until he finds his own henchman. He turns his own nephew to the Dark Side, the disappears to the shadows while Ren wreaks havoc on a helpless galaxy. All the while, controlling him through the simple expedient of a fake, Wizard of Oz-type hologram as “Snoke”.It’s air-tight. You know you can’t argue with logic. Luke is Snoke.